MHW-3BOMBER - Dec 11 2024
What Is the Difference Between Pour-Over Coffee and Siphon Coffee?Which One Tastes Better?
Recently, we've received questions from users asking about the difference between pour-over coffee and siphon coffee. What is the difference in taste? Today, let's take a look at the distinctions between these two brewing methods.
What is Pour-Over Coffee? What is Siphon Coffee?
Let's start by looking at the main differences between pour-over coffee and siphon coffee:
| Comparison Aspect | Pour-Over Coffee | Siphon Coffee |
|---|---|---|
| Difficulty Level | Relatively simple, suitable for beginners | Complex, requires experience and skill |
| Tools Needed | Dripper, filter paper, pour-over kettle | Siphon pot, filter cloth, heating equipment |
| Extraction Principle | Gravity and manual control of water flow | Steam pressure and vacuum effect |
| Flavor Profile | Clean, layered, emphasizes the natural flavors of the coffee beans | Rich aroma, full-bodied taste with both depth and smoothness |
| Visual Appeal | Simple to operate, lower visual appeal | Strong sense of ritual, great for performance and experience |
| Suitable Context | Home use and daily coffee consumption | High-end occasions or special experiences |
Pour-Over Coffee
Pour-over coffee, also known as drip coffee, is a brewing method that uses a dripper and filter paper to manually control the flow rate and direction of water to extract the flavors of coffee.
Characteristics:
Tools: Common tools include a pour-over kettle, dripper, filter paper, and coffee pot.
Method: Hot water is poured over the coffee grounds in a slow and even manner, allowing the coffee liquid to drip through the filter paper into the container.
Taste: Focuses on a well-layered flavor profile, often highlighting fruity, floral, and balanced sweet-tart notes.
Ideal For: Those who enjoy fine-tuning and exploring the nuances of coffee.
We often hear the term "pour-over coffee" in many coffee shops, where the barista's brewing process has a sense of ritual. But honestly, pour-over coffee is just about pouring hot water over coffee grounds, extracting the coffee through filter paper and the dripper. However, depending on the type of dripper, brewing parameters, and pouring technique, the resulting flavor can vary greatly, making the method highly skill-dependent. The process is quite meticulous and requires a lot of technique.
Since pour-over coffee is primarily a filter brewing method, it requires attention to factors like pouring technique, water temperature, and grind size. Due to the use of filter paper, the flavor tends to be cleaner, and the coffee liquid appears clear.
MHW-3BOMBER Assassin M1 Pour Over Coffee Set Deluxe
Siphon Coffee
Siphon coffee is a brewing method that uses steam pressure and vacuum principles to extract coffee. It is often regarded as a visually impressive and vintage-style brewing technique.
Characteristics:
Tools: Siphon pot, alcohol lamp or electric stove, filter cloth or filter paper, etc.
Scientific Principle: After heating, water is pushed into the upper chamber by steam pressure, where it mixes with the coffee grounds. Once heating stops, the liquid is drawn back to the lower chamber through vacuum pressure.
Flavor Profile: The coffee has a rich aroma, smooth texture, and combines the clean taste of pour-over with the full-bodied richness of espresso.
Ritualistic Appeal: The siphon method is often referred to as the "art performance of coffee" due to its elegant operation and unique equipment design.
Brewing coffee with a siphon pot gives an impression of sophistication, almost like conducting an experiment in a laboratory. The main principle of siphon coffee extraction is based on pressure differences. First, water in the lower chamber is heated to boiling. Then, the upper chamber is inserted, creating high pressure in the lower chamber. Due to the pressure difference between the two chambers, the hot water rises and mixes with the coffee grounds in the upper chamber, extracting the coffee. After the extraction process is complete, the heat source is removed from the lower chamber, causing the pressure difference to rapidly decrease, and the siphon effect causes the brewed coffee to return to the lower chamber.
Siphon coffee brewing is primarily an immersion process, which results in a more balanced coffee with a smooth, rich taste.
MHW-3BOMBER × Yu’en Zhang Twilight Siphon Coffee Maker
Brewing Experience
So, what are the characteristics of the coffee produced by these two brewing methods? To explore this, we brewed a pot of Yemen Mocha using both the pour-over and siphon methods. The resulting flavors highlight the differences between the two methods, showcasing their unique qualities and the varied brewing experiences they offer.
Pour-Over Method
Grind Size: 70-100 (Sniper Electric Coffee Grinder)
Coffee-to-Water Ratio: 1:15
Water Temperature: 89°C
Brew Time: 2'02"
Method:
1.Bloom with 26g of water for 30 seconds.
2.Pour water up to 125g in stages.
3.Continue pouring until 226g, and stop when the water level is about to expose the coffee bed.
4.Remove the dripper as the water level drops.
Taste: The pour-over method of brewing Yemen Mocha brings out a bright yet smooth and rounded grape-like acidity. The aftertaste is rich with dark chocolate notes, and the flavor is layered and complex.
Siphon Method
Grind Size: 110-140 (Sniper Electric Coffee Grinder)
Coffee-to-Water Ratio: 1:12
Water Temperature: 92-95°C
Brew Time: 1'25" after water boils
Method:
1.When the water reaches the upper chamber, add the coffee grounds.
2.Stir in a cross pattern for 2 rotations.
3.After 35 seconds, stir in circles for 5 rotations.
4.After 50 seconds, remove the heat source and wipe the lower chamber with a damp cloth to allow the coffee liquid to return.
Taste: Siphon-brewed Yemen Mocha results in a full-bodied, well-balanced cup. It features a smooth, rounded fruit acidity, with flavors of grapes and red berries on the palate. The dark chocolate notes are pronounced, and there is a lasting caramel sweetness in the aftertaste.
Comparison:
| Yemen Mocha Coffee | ||
|---|---|---|
| Pour-Over | Siphon | |
| Body | ☆ | ☆☆ |
| Acidity | ☆☆ | ☆ |
| Flavor | ☆☆☆ | ☆☆ |
| Balance | ☆☆ | ☆☆☆ |
Conclusion
Indeed, the biggest difference between Pour-Over and Siphon coffee lies in the body and balance. Coffee brewed with a siphon tends to have a richer mouthfeel and a more balanced overall flavor. On the other hand, pour-over coffee places more emphasis on flavor complexity, especially in the expression of acidity and fruitiness, which often makes it appear more refined and fresh.
As for which one tastes better, it ultimately depends on your personal preference. If you enjoy a richer, more balanced coffee, siphon coffee might be the better choice. However, if you prefer layered flavors and a stronger emphasis on fruitiness, pour-over coffee might be more to your liking.
Both methods have their own merits, so it’s all about choosing the brewing style that suits your taste.
